Review Structure
My reviews will start out with a blurb on
why I read this book so as to give readers a sense of my expectation bias. This will include things like cover evaluations and thoughts on the title's appropriateness. I will also include the
first lines from the novel to give readers a feel of the author's writing.
I will then begin the review with an
overall score in terms of how the whole book came together - note that this score is not necessarily an average of the other categories. The rest of the review is broken down into three categories:
plot/themes - where I evaluate the storyline and the subjects it broaches (ex. plot holes, social commentary, topics of debate)
characters - where I evaluate the character portrayals and growth (or lack thereof), as well as representation (ex. ethnic minorities, women, anti-heroes)
writing/art - where I evaluate the stylistic flow and reading level of the book, or the art composition if it is a graphic novel (ex. grammar, simple vs. stylistic, detailed vs. sparse)
I will also include an evaluation of the
ending of each book, taking into account whether it is in a series or a stand-alone, and the quality of the resolutions the last pages provide.
Rating System
All scores will be marked out of five and may include partial scores.
☂☂☂☂☂ 1 umbrella: could not finish
☂☂☂☂☂ 2 umbrella: at least it tried
☂☂☂☂☂ 3 umbrella: not amazing, but not bad
☂☂☂☂☂ 4 umbrella: well worth your time
☂☂☂☂☂ 5 umbrella: definite shelf-keeper
favourites: ♥
my personal favourites, regardless of rating 8D
I also submit reviews to
Amazon.ca,
Book Depository,
goodreads,
LibraryThing, and
Shelfari.
Publishers & Authors
If you would like to guest post, participate in an interview, or send me a book for review or to give away, please contact me using
this form or email me at
ninefly(at)gmail(dot)com! Please note my mailing address is Canadian.
My preferred genres:
paranormal ; urban fantasy ; horror ; mystery/thriller ; sci-fi ; fantasy ; Asian themed
I'm open to:
self-published books ; translated titles ; glbt ; graphic novels ; audio books
I will usually NOT review:
children's books ; erotic romance ; health/beauty/inspirational/memoirs
BOOK REVIEWS
★ YA Fiction ★ Adult Fiction ★ Graphic Novels ★ Non-Fiction ★
OTHER REVIEWS
★ Movie Reviews ★
YA FICTION
Bell, Hilari
§
Knight and Rogue
- The Last Knight (rated ☂☂☂☂.5 in 2009 ♥)
Brennan, Sarah Rees
§
Demons Trilogy
- The Demon's Lexicon (rated ☂☂☂.5 in 2009)
Cashore, Kristin
§
Seven Kingdoms Trilogy
- Graceling (rated ☂☂☂ in 2010)
Ellis, Helen
§
The Turning Series
- What Curiosity Kills (rated ☂☂☂ in 2010)
Levithan, David
Moore, Perry
- Hero (rated ☂☂.5 in 2010)
Nayeri, Daniel & Dina
§
Another Series
- Another Faust (rated ☂☂☂☂ in 2010)
ADULT FICTION
Ballard, J.G.
Carriger, Gail
§
Parasol Protectorate Series
- Soulless (rated ☂☂☂☂.5 in 2010 ♥)
Doyle, Arthur Conan
§
Sherlock Holmes Novels
- A Study in Scarlet (rated ☂☂☂☂ in 2010)
- The Sign of the Four (rated ☂☂☂☂.5 in 2010)
§
Sherlock Holmes Anthologies
- The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (rated ☂☂☂☂ in 2010)
Flewelling, Lynn
§
Nightrunner
- Luck in the Shadows (rated ☂☂☂☂.5 ♥ in 2010)
Landay, William
Monette, Sarah
§
Doctrine of Labyrinths
- Mélusine (rated ☂☂☂.5 in 2009)
- The Virtu (rated ☂☂☂☂ in 2009 ♥)
Palahniuk, Chuck
Pratt, T.A.
§
Marla Mason
- Blood Engines (rated ☂☂☂☂ in 2009)
- Poison Sleep (rated ☂☂☂.5 in 2010)
Shatner, William
§
Star Trek Academy
- Collision Course (rated ☂☂☂☂ in 2010)
GRAPHIC NOVELS
Minekura, Kazuya
Oda, Eiichiro
Quesada, Joe
Sorachi, Hideaki
NON-FICTION
Knight, Rachelle Rogers